Guardiola denies exit but City's succession debate has begun

Guardiola dismisses exit talk but City's succession planning is already underway. What his continued presence means tactically — and why Maresca makes sense as a contingency.

By Sarah WhitmorePublished Dec 19, 2025, 5:37 PMUpdated Dec 19, 2025, 5:37 PM
Man City

© Jonny Gios

Pep Guardiola has moved to quash speculation about his Manchester City future, but the bigger question isn't whether he stays — it's what his continued presence means for City's tactical evolution and succession planning.

Speaking ahead of Manchester City's Premier League clash with West Ham, the 54-year-old addressed reports from The Athletic suggesting he could leave at the end of the season, with Chelsea boss Enzo Maresca identified as a potential successor.

What Guardiola actually said

The Catalan was characteristically measured in his response: "The club has to be prepared, but that subject is not on the table right now."

He added: "I have 18 months left. I'm so delighted, happy, excited in the development of the team." When pressed further, Guardiola offered a pragmatic view: "Even if I had a 10-year contract, or six months, football changes a lot."

This isn't a denial of departure — it's an acknowledgment that elite football management operates in perpetual uncertainty.

The tactical implications of stability

Guardiola's continued presence carries significant weight for City's on-pitch identity. This season has seen a tactical recalibration after last year's struggles:

  • More vertical play: Erling Haaland has scored three goals via fast breaks — a league high. City are increasingly direct when the opportunity arises.
  • Doku's role as a progressive carrier: The Belgian leads the Premier League for ball carries ending in the opposition box (72) and chances created following a carry (11).
  • Phil Foden's resurgence: Guardiola declared "Phil is back!" after his brace against Borussia Dortmund — a critical piece of the attacking puzzle.

This evolution isn't accidental. It reflects Guardiola's ability to adapt his principles to personnel, something that would inevitably shift under a different manager — even one schooled in Pep's methods like Maresca.

Why Maresca makes sense as a contingency

The Athletic's report linking Maresca isn't merely speculation. The Italian spent the 2022/23 treble-winning campaign as Guardiola's assistant, absorbing the City methodology at close range. His work at Chelsea — transforming a chaotic squad into title contenders — demonstrates he can implement possession-based systems at the highest level.

City's hierarchy aren't naive. Under director of football Hugo Viana, the club has restructured its backroom staff this season, promoting Kolo Touré and integrating Pepijn Lijnders. These moves suggest preparation for eventual transition, regardless of when Guardiola departs.

City's position in the title race

Context matters here. City sit just two points behind Arsenal following six consecutive wins across all competitions. They beat Real Madrid 2-1 at the Bernabéu earlier this month, moving fourth in the Champions League league phase.

Guardiola himself tempered expectations: "In the way we play, still we are not at the level required to compete to win the titles, but the margin is there to improve it."

This is classic Guardiola — publicly demanding more while privately knowing the trajectory is positive. His teams rarely peak in December.

The bottom line

Guardiola isn't leaving imminently. But City's willingness to publicly acknowledge succession planning — even indirectly through Ornstein's report — suggests the club is preparing for the inevitable.

For now, the focus remains on West Ham, then Nottingham Forest, then the fixtures that will define City's season. The Guardiola era continues, but the post-Pep conversation has officially begun.

SW
Sarah Whitmore

A 32-year-old English journalist from London. Expert in the Premier League, FA Cup and English women’s football. She also covers English clubs in the Champions League, Europa League and Conference League, and monitors English players in other top leagues (Spain, Germany, Italy). Passionate about data, she interprets tactical trends and evolutions in the game.