Newcastle vs Fulham live: Magpies and Cottagers locked in tense Carabao Cup battle

Newcastle and Fulham are locked in a tactical battle at St James' Park as the holders seek to extend their Carabao Cup run while the Cottagers look to spring a surprise in this quarter-final tie.

By Sarah WhitmorePublished Dec 17, 2025, 9:50 PMUpdated Dec 17, 2025, 9:52 PM

St James' Park is witnessing an enthralling Carabao Cup quarter-final as Newcastle United and Fulham trade blows in a contest where both sides have shown clear intent to progress to the semi-finals.

Tactical Setup: Two Different Approaches

Eddie Howe has deployed a 4-3-3 formation with an interesting twist: Yoane Wissa leads the line ahead of the recovering Nick Woltemade, whose own goal sealed Newcastle's derby defeat to Sunderland. The Congolese striker's inclusion signals Howe's intent to find more fluency in the final third after the sterile performance at the Stadium of Light (0.54 xG).

Marco Silva has responded with a 4-3-2-1 shape, Emile Smith Rowe pulling the strings behind Raúl Jiménez. The absence of Calvin Bassey, Samuel Chukwueze, and Alex Iwobi due to Africa Cup of Nations duty has forced Silva's hand, but the system is designed to exploit transitions – exactly what troubled Burnley when Fulham generated 2.23 xG at Turf Moor.

First Half Analysis: Newcastle's Dominance, Fulham's Resilience

The Magpies have controlled territory as expected, with Bruno Guimarães orchestrating from deep. His ability to break Fulham's first pressing line has created space for Harvey Barnes on the left flank. However, the visitors' compact 4-3-2-1 has limited clear-cut chances.

Key observations:

  • Lewis Miley is being asked to cover enormous ground, compensating for the defensive absence of Dan Burn
  • Harry Wilson's positioning between Newcastle's centre-backs and full-backs is causing hesitation in Howe's defensive setup
  • Bernd Leno has already made two crucial saves, maintaining Fulham's threat on the counter

The Critical Battle: Midfield Control

The duel between Guimarães and Sander Berge is defining this tie. Both are averaging over 90% pass completion in their respective halves, but the spaces are appearing in transition moments. Newcastle's eight-game winning run in the Carabao Cup has been built on controlling these phases – tonight, that control is being contested.

What to Watch in the Second Half

Fulham's extra day of rest could prove decisive. Silva's side played Saturday; Newcastle only featured on Sunday. With tired legs comes tactical sloppiness, and the Cottagers' ability to exploit half-spaces through Smith Rowe and Josh King will test Newcastle's depleted defensive options.

The holders want a third consecutive semi-final appearance – something they've never achieved. Fulham seek to end a run of five quarter-final eliminations in six attempts. The tactical chess continues.

Live updates will follow as this quarter-final unfolds at St James' Park.

Related Teams, Competitions & Players

SW
Sarah Whitmore

A 32-year-old English journalist from London. Expert in the Premier League, FA Cup and English women’s football. She also covers English clubs in the Champions League, Europa League and Conference League, and monitors English players in other top leagues (Spain, Germany, Italy). Passionate about data, she interprets tactical trends and evolutions in the game.